“…A key obstacle in the interpretation of geochemical data from marine sediments as proxies for chemical weathering is to constrain their sources and the mechanism and strength of sediment transport processes because changes in provenance can affect these proxies and, thus, the environmental interpretation (Clift et al, ; Colin et al, ; Hu et al, ; Li et al, ; Wan et al, ; Xiong et al, ; Zheng et al, ). If the source can be constrained, then the sediment fluxes and transport processes involved can be related to continental weathering/erosion intensity and rates, mostly those associated with a monsoon climate (Bian et al, ; Cai et al, ; Chen et al, ; Clift et al, ; Wan et al, ; Xu et al, ; Zhao et al, ). We cannot assume that modern fluvial sediments are similar to older sediments because large changes have been recorded over glacial cycles (Clift et al, ), and over the past 5 Ma, there have been major changes in the isotope composition of the Indus River, originally linked to drainage reorganization (Clift & Blusztajn , ) but now argued to be linked to unroofing of new source regions (Chirouze et al, ).…”