A Green New Balance: Interactions among riparian vegetation plant traits and morphodynamics in alluvial rivers

Abstract

The strength of interactions between plants and river processes is mediated by plant traits and fluvial conditions, including above-ground biomass, stem density and flexibility, channel and bed-material properties, and flow and sediment regimes. In many rivers, concurrent changes in (1) the composition of riparian vegetation communities as a result of exotic species invasion and (2) shifts in hydrology have altered physical and ecological conditions in a manner that has been mediated by feedbacks between vegetation and morphodynamic processes. We review how Tamarix, which has invaded many southwestern US waterways, and Populus species, woody pioneer trees that are native to the region, differentially affect hydraulics, sediment transport, and river morphology. We draw on flume, field, and modelling approaches spanning the individual seedling to river-corridor scales. In a flume study, we found that differences in the crown morphology, stem density, and flexibility of Tamarix compared to Populus influenced near-bed flow velocities in a manner that favoured aggradation associated with Tamarix. Similarly, at the patch and corridor scales, observations confirmed increased aggradation with increased vegetation density. Furthermore, longterm channel adjustments were different for Tamarix-versus Populus-dominated reaches, with faster and greater geomorphic adjustments for Tamarix. Collectively, our studies show how plant-trait differences between Tamarix and Populus, from individual seedlings to larger spatial and temporal scales, influence the co-adjustment of rivers and riparian plant communities. These findings provide a basis for predicting changes in alluvial riverine systems which we conceptualize as a Green New Balance model that considers how channels may adjust to changes in plant traits and community structure, in addition to alterations in flow and sediment supply. We offer suggestions regarding how the Green New Balance can be used in management and invasive species management.

Introduction to the Women in Geomorphology special issue

“…Remote sensing ( 26) Agostini et al, 2022;Atwood & West, 2022;Davies et al, 2022;Davis et al, 2021;Fadul et al, 2022;Gervasi et al, 2021;Hendrickx et al, 2022;Hodge & Buechel, 2022;Hooke, 2022;Hovenga et al, 2021;Konlechner & Hilton, 2022;Lefebvre et al, 2022;Marchetti et al, 2022;McKenzie et al, 2022;Mol & Grenfell, 2022;Opalka et al, 2022;Rabanaque et al, 2022;Regalla et al, 2022;Reitman et al, 2022;Sampietro-Vattuone et al, 2021;Schoch-Baumann et al, 2022;Thompson et al, 2022;Vah et al, 2022;Valentine et al, 2022;Zhang et al, 2022 Physical experiments (8) Bako et al, 2022;Bywater-Reyes et al, 2022;Demiral et al, 2022;Friedrich et al, 2022;Negreiros et al, 2022;Rachelly et al, 2022;Roelofs et al, 2022;Vah et al, 2022 Numerical models ( 11) Agostini et al, 2022;Bywater-Reyes et al, 2022;Cullen et al, 2022;Glover et al, 2022;Hodge & Buechel, 2022;Kooijma...…”

“…Field (26) Atkins et al, 2023;Bernatek-Jakiel & Nadal-Romero, 2023;Biausque et al, 2022;Brooks et al, 2022;Bywater-Reyes et al, 2022;Chin, 2022;Gervasi et al, 2021;Glover et al, 2022; Goodman et al, in press;Guiney & Lininger, 2022; Gurnell et al, 2022;Harvey et al, 2022;Hinshaw et al, 2022;Hooke, 2022;Konlechner & Hilton, 2022;Kooijman et al, 2022;Lane et al, 2022;Lefebvre et al, 2022;Marchetti et al, 2022;McKeon et al, 2022;Mol & Grenfell, 2022;Mossa & Chen, 2022;Opalka et al, 2022;Patton et al, 2022;Quock et al, 2022;Regalla et al, 2022;Reitman et al, 2022;Sampietro-Vattuone et al, 2021;Schoch-Baumann et al, 2022;Souza Fonseca et al, 2022;Spiske et al, 2022;Thompson et al, 2022;Uphues et al, 2022;Valentine et al, 2022;Van Soest et al, 2022;Wohl, 2022;Zhang et al, 2022 (Continues)…”

“…Many of the major research directions in contemporary geomorphology are reflected in this collection of papers. With respect to fluvial environments, including alluvial fans, individual papers examine use of images to detect sediment motion during physical experiments (Vah et al, 2022); comparison of grain‐size distributions from field measurements and remotely acquired images (Marchetti et al, 2022); physical experiments on bedload saltation under differing conditions (Demiral et al, 2022); numerical modelling of critical shear stress for grain entrainment based on imagery of bed‐rock channels (Hodge & Buechel, 2022); biogeomorphology (Bywater‐Reyes et al, 2022; Gurnell et al, 2022); channel morphology and classification (Lane et al, 2022), hydromorphology of ephemeral streams (Rabanaque et al, 2022) and interpretation of geomorphic unit assemblages (Fryirs & Brierley, 2022); flood effectiveness (Gervasi et al, 2021); channel evolution, terraces and sediment sources (Guyez et al, 2022) and the influence of sediment supply on gravel‐bed river widening (Rachelly et al, 2022); hydrological variation and meander morphodynamics (Hooke, 2022); the dynamics of wood in river corridors (Guiney & Lininger, 2022; Gurnell et al, 2022; Wohl, 2022) and numerical modelling of wood‐related processes (Friedrich et al, 2022); numerical model validation (Negreiros et al, 2022) and numerical modelling of groundwater‐driven network evolution (Cullen et al, 2022); base‐level controls and landscape evolution (Fadul et al, 2022); long‐term dryland channel response to urbanization (Chin, 2022); watershed restoration and management, including human alterations of process and form (Atkins et al, 2023; Davis et al, 2021; Goodman et al, in press; Gurnell et al, 2022; Hinshaw et al, 2022; Mossa & Chen, 2022; Sampietro‐Vattuone et al, 2021; Valentine et al, 2022); and alluvial fan dynamics (Opalka et al, 2022; Quock et al, 2022; Regalla et al, 2022; Schoch‐Baumann et al, 2022). Papers addressing process and form in coastal environments include examinations of dune morphodynamics and evolution (Hovenga et al,...…”

Floodplain characteristics affect woody vegetation regeneration on point bars of a coastal plain river recovering from anthropogenic disturbances

“…For example, ground‐based and airborne LiDAR (light detection and ranging) data were used to assess multiscale influence of woody riparian vegetation on fluvial topography (Bywater‐Reyes et al, 2017). Flume experiments and numerical modellings have been used to investigate the feedback between woody riparian vegetation and other floodplain characteristics (i.e., Bertoldi et al, 2015; Bywater‐Reyes et al, 2022; Lightbody et al, 2019; Wu et al, 2005). For instance, Lightbody et al (2019) focused on examining the presence and absence of riparian vegetation to sediment transport, topographic and hydraulic using an outdoor experimental facility.…”

The Influence of Knickpoint Development and Channel Incision on Riparian Vegetation in Semi‐Arid River Corridors

“…Multiple studies have investigated linkages between flow, geomorphic processes and form, and riparian vegetation composition and abundance (e.g., Bywater-Reyes et al, 2022;Diehl et al, 2017Diehl et al, , 2018. For example, stream incision in urban systems due to increased runoff has been shown to reduce understory vegetation cover in riparian zones, as well as change riparian vegetation composition (Solins & Cadenasso, 2020, 2022.…”