A critical analysis of articles using a Gadamerian based research method

Abstract

It is over 20 years since Michael Crotty's groundbreaking critique of phenomenological research in nursing. However, rather than entering into the acrimonious discussions that followed, we developed a research method that we believed translated Gadamer's philosophy into the world of empirical research. Fundamental to that work was our differentiation of hermeneutics from phenomenology. The aim of the present paper was to provide a critical analysis of the citations from publication in 2003 until the end of 2017. We identified 402 citations of which 362 were included. One hundred and sixty‐three articles mentioned the article in passing, usually in a list of authors who had discussed hermeneutics. Sixteen citations misrepresented the method mainly claiming that we discussed a method for hermeneutic phenomenology (or phenomenological hermeneutics). Of the 117 citations that partially used the method, the main focus was the four steps of data analysis. Sixty studies used our method in totality although they derive from varying philosophical standpoints. Disappointingly, there has been little critique of our Gadamerian research method. For health disciplines to truly make progress in the academic stage, it is vital that we engage in with critique, some of which will come through open and honest reflexive engagement with our topics.

Social Support in Patients With Sexual Dysfunction After Non-Nerve-Sparing Radical Prostatectomy: A Qualitative Study

“…The understanding of a phenomenon is achieved through a fusion of horizons between the researchers (preunderstanding) and the participants (based on their experiences) (Gadamer, 2013). The development of this study followed the phases of the Gadamerian-based research method (Fleming et al, 2003; Fleming & Rob, 2019) as follows:…”

Sustainability Transition in Industry 4.0 and Smart Manufacturing with the Triple-Layered Business Model Canvas

“…The interviews were audited and then digitally transcribed for subsequent evaluation of the results. The approach followed to interpret the results of the interviews was a phenomenological hermeneutical one inspired by Gadamer's vision [63] and applied by Settembre-Blundo et al (2019) [64] using a hermeneutical circle as a tool to interpret reality. The interpretation process involved three stages:…”

Experiências sexuais após prostatectomia radical não poupadora de nervos

“…Desenho do estudo Estudo exploratório, qualitativo, descritivo, baseado na fenomenologia hermenêutica de Gadame. (22) some participants question their usual sexual practices and try to adapt to a holistic sexuality not centered on coitus by incorporating innovative forms of sexuality.…”

“…(23) A compreensão da narrativa dos participantes requer preparo para um diálogo a partir do qual irão emergir diferentes significados. (22) Local e população Este estudo foi realizado na sede local da Associação Espanhola contra o Câncer -AECC (Asociación Española contra el Cáncer). Os participantes foram recrutados através de uma técnica de amostragem por conveniência.…”