A comparison of tympanic and rectal temperatures in term NIGERIAN neonates

Abstract

BackgroundTympanic thermometry has come as a suitable alternative to traditional thermometry because of its safety and ease of use. However, it is still yet to gain wide acceptance in African settings due to conflicting results on its accuracy, thus rectal thermometry remains the gold standard in the newborn. The aim of this study was to compare tympanic and rectal temperatures in term Nigerian neonates.MethodsRectal and tympanic temperatures were measured simultaneously in 300 consecutive term neonates between the ages of 37 and 42 weeks gestation using mercury-in-glass and the Infrared tympanic thermometers respectively. Paired t test, Pearson correlation coefficient and the Bland-Altman plot were used to compute data. Using rectal thermometry as gold standard, the sensitivity, specificity and predictive values of tympanic thermometry at various rectal temperature cut-offs were determined. Receiver Operating Curves (ROC) were constructed and the Areas Under the Curves (AUC) were compared.ResultsThe mean rectal temperature (37.34 ± 0.55°C) was significantly higher than the mean tympanic temperature (37.25 ± 0.56°C) (p < 0.001) with a mean difference of 0.09 °C ± 0.24 °C (95% CI: 0.06, 0.12). There was a strong positive correlation between the two measurements (r = 0.9; p < 0.001). Tympanic thermometry showed sensitivities ranging from 65% to 86% and specificities of 95% to 99% at rectal temperature cut-offs of 37.5°C to 38°C. The positive and negative predictive values of the tympanic temperatures at the various temperature cut-offs ranged from 82% to 93% and 80% to 98% respectively. Accuracy was noted to increase with higher temperatures as shown by the Receiver Operating Curves with the highest accuracy at the temperature cut-off of 38°C and AUC of 0.91.ConclusionsThe sensitivity of tympanic thermometry was relatively low in detecting rectal temperatures despite the good correlation and agreement between them. The specificities and predictive values of tympanic temperatures in detecting rectal temperatures were high and accuracy increased with higher temperatures. Though using the tympanic route for measuring temperature in the newborn is relatively safe and non-invasive, its low sensitivity limits its use. Further studies would be required to further assess the accuracy of tympanic temperature measurements in the newborn.

Performance of infrared ear and forehead thermometers: a comparative study in 205 febrile and afebrile children

“…On the other hand, Duru et al . () reported low sensitivity of readings with an ear thermometer in newborns, although specificity was high in this population.…”

Consistency Assessment of Heat Stress Monitoring of Outdoor Workers Using Sweat Rate Measurement and Wet Bulb Globe Temperature WBGT in Arid and Semi-Arid Climates

“…Therefore, detailed analysis through accurate rational indices such as predicted heat strain (PHS) or heat related physiological responses are strongly recommended whenever primary heat stress condition is observed (9). Core temperature, especially rectal temperature as well as sweat rate, are two parameters that create the best correlation in accordance with changes in environmental thermal condition (9,10). However, applicability and adoption of both were restricted in real field studies due to the very sophisticated and difficult measurement methods (in the case of sweat rate) and also ethical and cultural issues (in the case of rectal temperature).…”

Cost-effective therapeutic hypothermia treatment device for hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy

“…The microprocessor uses a temperature reading from a rectal monitoring sensor to determine which LED light to turn on. A green LED light is turned on if the rectal temperature is within 33.5°C ± 1°C during cooling, while a yellow LED is turned on to warn the nurse that the rectal temperature is not within the desired temperature range 27. A skin monitoring sensor is used as an additional safeguard to prevent any drastic change in temperature and dangers caused by a failure of rectal monitoring.…”