A comparison of methods to assess the antimicrobial activity of nanoparticle combinations on bacterial cells

Abstract

BackgroundBacterial cell quantification after exposure to antimicrobial compounds varies widely throughout industry and healthcare. Numerous methods are employed to quantify these antimicrobial effects. With increasing demand for new preventative methods for disease control, we aimed to compare and assess common analytical methods used to determine antimicrobial effects of novel nanoparticle combinations on two different pathogens.MethodsPlate counts of total viable cells, flow cytometry (LIVE/DEAD BacLight viability assay) and qPCR (viability qPCR) were used to assess the antimicrobial activity of engineered nanoparticle combinations (NPCs) on Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus) and Gram-negative (Pseudomonas aeruginosa) bacteria at different concentrations (0.05, 0.10 and 0.25 w/v%). Results were analysed using linear models to assess the effectiveness of different treatments.ResultsStrong antimicrobial effects of the three NPCs (AMNP0–2) on both pathogens could be quantified using the plate count method and flow cytometry. The plate count method showed a high log reduction (>8-log) for bacteria exposed to high NPC concentrations. We found similar antimicrobial results using the flow cytometry live/dead assay. Viability qPCR analysis of antimicrobial activity could not be quantified due to interference of NPCs with qPCR amplification.ConclusionFlow cytometry was determined to be the best method to measure antimicrobial activity of the novel NPCs due to high-throughput, rapid and quantifiable results.

AVNP2 protects against cognitive impairments induced by C6 glioma by suppressing tumour associated inflammation in rats

“…It has been proved that AMNPs and AVNPs, such as Ag(Ag + ), Cu (Cu 2+ ) and Zn(Zn 2+ ), have been developed with proven efficacy (99.999%) against both Gram-positive (G + ) and Gram-negative (G − ) bacteria (Cheong et al, 2017;Ren et al, 2009;Bankier et al, 2018), which is similar or close to antibiotic properties in-vitro (Wan et al, 2016). The nano-intermetallics (i.e., AVNP2) can especially effectively inactivate bacteria and inhibit bacterial biofilm formation through ionic releases (0.1-5 ppm of [Cu 2+ -[Ag + ]) enhanced by their surface charge (Zeta protentional (< −40 mv (Nan et al, 2016;Nan et al, 2015;Ren, 2015Ren, , 2016 and surface free energy (> 70 mJ/m 2 ) (Nan et al, 2015) Terahertz (THz) radiation (He et al, 2018) is useful for a number of scientific and industrial applications, such as molecular spectroscopy, high data-rate communication, and material studies.…”

Co‐Culture of Keratinocyte‐Staphylococcus aureus on Cu‐Ag‐Zn/CuO and Cu‐Ag‐W Nanoparticle Loaded Bacterial Cellulose:PMMA Bandages

“…Many studies on Ag NPs and Cu NPs have addressed the treatment of multidrug‐resistant species by using Ag NPs, where last resort antibiotics have failed to contain the infection. Some pioneering work by Ren and co‐workers., on Ag, Cu, and other metal nanocomposites against methicillin‐resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) demonstrated significant minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) reduction and killing rate (99.999%). At the same time, the Ag‐Cu NP combinations are able to kill a wider spectrum of bacteria and are expected to reduce inflammation as well as allow for better wound healing with minimal tissue scarring .…”

“…The majority of the constituents in AVNP‐2 were intended to increase the synergistic effect between Ag‐Cu and carbon NPs. A high‐level content of sp 2 CC powder in AVNP‐2 was used for achieving a significant reduction in cell toxicity …”

“…A high-level content of sp 2 CC powder in AVNP-2 was used for achieving a significant reduction in cell toxicity. [15][16][17]21,22] Wound dressing manufacture requires the generation of fiber mat bandages with high yield. A novel method of production, pressurized gyration, which is based on production of polymeric fibers using the application of centrifugal force and dynamic fluid flow under pressure has resulted in significant results compared to other methods (e.g., electrospinning).…”

Nano/Micromotors for Diagnosis and Therapy of Cancer and Infectious Diseases

“…Indeed, silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) are widely used in the killing of pathogenic cells (bacteria) due to its large surface area, which improves the contact with pathogenic cells and results in higher antibacterial efficiency compared to traditional Ag salts. After interaction with bacteria, Ag + ions are released from gaps at a desired rate and location according to their size or surface coating . Such interesting feature has been explored by the micromotor community in a myriad of configurations and related applications.…”