Phenomenological aspects of the cognitive rumination construct

Abstract

Objective: To evaluate the importance of phenomenological aspects of the cognitive rumination (CR) construct in current empirical psychiatric research. Method: We searched SciELO, Scopus, ScienceDirect, MEDLINE, OneFile (GALE), SpringerLink, Cambridge Journals and Web of Science between February and March of 2014 for studies whose title and topic included the following keywords: cognitive rumination; rumination response scale; and self-reflection. The inclusion criteria were: empirical clinical study; CR as the main object of investigation; and study that included a conceptual definition of CR. The studies selected were published in English in biomedical journals in the last 10 years. Our phenomenological analysis was based on Karl Jaspers' General Psychopathology. Results: Most current empirical studies adopt phenomenological cognitive elements in conceptual definitions. However, these elements do not seem to be carefully examined and are indistinctly understood as objective empirical factors that may be measured, which may contribute to misunderstandings about CR, erroneous interpretations of results and problematic theoretical models. Conclusion:Empirical studies fail when evaluating phenomenological aspects of the cognitive elements of the CR construct. Psychopathology and phenomenology may help define the characteristics of CR elements and may contribute to their understanding and hierarchical organization as a construct. A review of the psychopathology principles established by Jasper may clarify some of these issues. Keywords: Psychopathology, phenomenology, cognitive rumination. ResumoObjetivo: Verificar a importância de aspectos fenomenológicos relacionados ao construto de ruminação cognitiva (RC) nas pesquisas empíricas psiquiátricas atuais. Método: Foram pesquisadas as bases de dados SciELO, Scopus, ScienceDirect, MEDLINE, OneFile (GALE), SpringerLink, Cambridge Journals e Web of Science, entre fevereiro e março de 2014, buscando artigos cujo tópico ou título contivessem os seguintes termos-chave: ruminação cognitiva; escala de resposta ruminativa; e autorreflexão. Os critérios de inclusão foram: estudos clínicos empíricos; RC como principal objeto de pesquisa; e estudos que incluíssem uma definição conceitual de RC. Foram considerados apenas artigos em inglês publicados em periódicos biomédicos nos últimos 10 anos. Nossa análise fenomenológica se fundamentou na Psicopatologia Geral de Jaspers. Resultados: Os conceitos de RC atualmente encontrados nas pesquisas empíricas utilizam majoritariamente elementos fenomenológicos em suas definições. Entretanto, esses elementos cognitivos são indistintamente entendidos como elementos objetivos (empíricos), passíveis de mensuração, e não parecem ser cuidadosamente examinados. Este fato pode contribuir para uma compreensão enganosa sobre RC, além de favorecer a interpretação errônea de resultados e a elaboração de paradoxos teóricos problemáticos. Conclusão: As pesquisas empíricas atuais sobre RC falham ao avaliar os aspectos fenomenológicos inerentes ao...

Criminal Responsibility Scale: Development and Validation of a Psychometric Tool Structured in Clinical Vignettes for Criminal Responsibility Assessments in Brazil

“…The CRS revealed objective criteria for determining CU and CD in the assessment of CR. The phenomenological nature of these LCs precludes an immediately objective determination and requires elements from psychopathology for its objective determination (2,13,(32)(33)(34)(35). Our study helps answer the following key question: What are the appropriate criteria of scientificity for subjective psychopathological constructs?…”

“…These characteristics also show how psychopathology, as a specific area of knowledge, is not limited to psychiatric assessment and is useful in other areas of knowledge, such as law (13,(32)(33)(34)(35). Additionally, it is the forensic psychiatrist's responsibility to precisely determine the correspondence between psychopathological elements of law and those applied in psychiatry (13,(32)(33)(34)(35).…”

“…Hence, the adoption of objective parameters for scoring answers in CRS enabled the statistical validation of these psychopathological constructs, according to the traditional theoretical model of CR (2,13). This model presents phenomenological (i.e., subjective) characteristics identical to those adopted by classical psychopathology (13,(32)(33)(34)(35).…”

“…The purpose of forensic psychiatry is to support judges and lawyers in developing the necessary legal reasoning for rulings on offenses (1,2). It is essential to focus on the specificities of concepts used in this area of knowledge, originally from the human sciences, and technically preserve their limits and practical objectives (13,(32)(33)(34)(35). To overstep such limits may compromise a judge's performance and the technical quality of forensic evidence used by the parties in the case, and thus irreversibly jeopardize the defendant's trial (1,2).…”

Associação entre uso de internet e autoconsciência ruminativa em universitários

“…Tal resultado pode ser explicado pelo fato de o estilo de autoconsciência ruminativa ser frequente na população, ainda que não acompanhado de sintomas mais graves de depressão, ansiedade, pânico, fobias, insônia, transtorno do déficit de atenção, por exemplo (Smith & Alloy, 2009;Zanon & Hutz, 2009). Isto é, a ruminação não é um estilo de autoconsciência relacionado, necessariamente, à máadaptação psicológica (Meyer et al, 2015) e, portanto, a um comportamento de dependência, ainda que explique em parte o uso descontrolado de Internet. Esse resultado é reforçado pelo baixo registro de queixas ou morbidades relatadas pelos participantes (apenas 12 participantes relataram possuir alguma doença mental ou física).…”