Comparing definitions of spatial relations for the analysis of geographic disparities in mortality within a Bayesian mixed-effects framework

Abstract

ABSTRACT:Objective: To analyze the conceptual and technical differences between three definitions of spatial relations within a Bayesian mixed-effects framework: classical multilevel definition, spatial multiple membership definition and conditional autoregressive definition with an illustration of the estimate of geographic disparities in early neonatal mortality in Colombia, 2011Colombia, -2014. Methods: A registry based cross-sectional study was conducted. Births and early neonatal deaths were obtained from the Colombian vital statistics registry for 2011-2014. Crude and adjusted Bayesian mixed effects regressions were performed for each definition of spatial relation. Model fit statistics, spatial autocorrelation of residuals and estimated mortality rates, geographic disparity measures, relative ratios and relative differences were compared. Results: The definition of spatial relations between municipalities based on the conditional autoregressive prior showed the best performance according to both fit statistics and residual spatial pattern analyses. Spatial multiple membership definition had a poor performance. Conclusion: Bayesian mixed effects regression with conditional autoregressive prior as an analytical framework may be an important contribution to epidemiological design as an improved alternative to ecological methods in the analyses of geographic disparities of mortality, considering potential ecological bias and spatial model misspecification.

Availability of secondary healthcare data for conducting pharmacoepidemiology studies in Colombia: A systematic review

“…Among these, 351 articles were excluded after title screening and the abstract of the 784 remaining papers was assessed. Finally, 461 publications were excluded following the eligibility criteria and thus, 323 articles that had interpretable data and fulfilled the eligibility criteria were used for data extraction…”

“…A total of 88 articles (27%) reported data from a government agency. The most frequently used data source was the vital statistics information, mainly on mortality, from the National Administrative Department of Statistics (DANE) 28,30,31,38,39,45,66,69,71,74,89,93,165,171,199,200,210,221,225,228,229,252,262,268,269,274,287,303,317,321,339 …”

Covid-19 hospital mortality using spatial hierarchical models: cohort design with 74,994 registers

“…Therefore, analyzing the phenomenon via individual data and considering contextual information hierarchically with robust methodologies that contemplate spatial dependency allows for a broader understanding of the phenomenon. Furthermore, this approach diminishes ecological and atomistic biases, and avoids spatial misspecification when analyzing geographic disparities 6 .…”