The development of neural tissue starts with the activation of early neural genes such as the SoxB1 transcription factors, which are expressed in response to signaling molecules. Neural progenitors in the inner ear are only generated in the anterior placodal domain, but the mechanisms that determine when and how otic neural fate is acquired are still unknown. Here, we show that Sox3 expression becomes restricted to the anterior territory of the chick otic field and that misexpression of Sox3 induces Sox2 and Delta1 in the non-neurogenic otic territory. This suggests that Sox3 plays a central role in the establishment of an otic neural fate. Furthermore, Sox3 down-regulates the expression of Lmx1b, a marker of the posterior non-neurogenic otic epithelium. The expression of Sox3 is maintained by the positive action of FGF8 derived from the otic ectoderm. On the contrary, BMP signaling does not have a major influence on neural commitment but instead regulates Lmx1b expression in the otic placode. Together, the data support the notion that Sox3 is critical for the development of the neural elements of the inner ear, and they highlight the importance of localized signaling from the ectoderm in establishing the neurogenic vs. non-neurogenic anteroposterior asymmetry that characterizes the early otic placode.

Otic neuronal precursors are the first cells to be specified and do so in the anterior domain of the otic placode, the proneural domain. In the present study, we have explored the early events of otic proneural regionalization in relation to the activity of the Notch signaling pathway. The proneural domain was characterized by the expression of Sox3, Fgf10 and members of the Notch pathway such as Delta1, Hes5 and Lunatic Fringe. The complementary non-neural domain expressed two patterning genes, Lmx1b and Iroquois1, and the members of the Notch pathway, Serrate1 and Hairy1. Fate map studies and double injections with DiI/DiO showed that labeled cells remained confined to anterior or posterior territories with limited cell intermingling. To explore whether Notch signaling pathway plays a role in the initial regionalization of the otic placode, Notch activity was blocked by a gamma-secretase inhibitor (DAPT). Notch blockade induced the expansion of non-neural genes, Lmx1 and Iroquois1, into the proneural domain. Combined gene expression and DiI experiments showed that these effects were not due to migration of non-neural cells into the proneural domain, suggesting that Notch activity regulates the expression of non-neural genes. This was further confirmed by the electroporation of a dominant-negative form of the Mastermind-like1 gene that caused the up-regulation of Lmx1 within the proneural domain. In addition, Notch pathway was involved in neuronal precursor selection, probably by a classical mechanism of lateral inhibition. We propose that the regionalization of the otic domain into a proneural and a non-neural territory is a very early event in otic development, and that Notch signaling activity is required to exclude the expression of non-neural genes from the proneural territory.

Vertebrate cranial sensory organs are derived from region at the border of the anterior neural plate called the pre-placodal region (PPR). The otic placode, the anlagen of the inner ear, is induced from PPR ectoderm by FGF signaling. We have previously shown that competence of embryonic ectoderm to respond to FGF signaling during otic placode induction correlates with the expression of PPR genes, but the molecular basis of this competence is poorly understood. Here, we characterize the function of a transcription factor, Foxi3 that is expressed at very early stages in the non-neural ectoderm and later in the PPR of chick embryos. Ablation experiments showed that the underlying hypoblast is necessary for the initiation of Foxi3 expression. Mis-expression of Foxi3 was sufficient to induce markers of non-neural ectoderm such as Dlx5, and the PPR such as Six1 and Eya2. Electroporation of Dlx5, or Six1 together with Eya1 also induced Foxi3, suggesting direct or indirect positive regulation between non-neural ectoderm genes and PPR genes. Knockdown of Foxi3 in chick embryos prevented the induction of otic placode markers, and was able to prevent competent cranial ectoderm from expressing otic markers in response to FGF2. In contrast, Foxi3 expression alone was not sufficient to confer competence to respond to FGF on embryonic ectoderm. Our analysis of PPR and FGF-responsive genes after Foxi3 knockdown at gastrula stages suggests it is not necessary for the expression of PPR genes at these stages, nor for the transduction of FGF signals. The early expression but late requirement for Foxi3 in ear induction suggests it may have some of the properties associated with pioneer transcription factors.

Foxi2 and Foxi3 are members of the Foxi class of Forkhead transcription factors. The Foxi transcription factor family has been shown to play roles in the development of the inner ear and pharyngeal arch derivatives in zebrafish. We describe the expression of Foxi2 and Foxi3 in chicken embryos during the first three days of embryonic development. Foxi3 is initially expressed broadly in the pre-placodal ectoderm surrounding the neural plate, which will give rise to all craniofacial sensory organs. It then becomes restricted to a region immediately anterior to the first pair of somites that will give rise to the otic and epibranchial placodes, before becoming down-regulated from this region and restricted to the ectoderm and endoderm of the pharyngeal arches. In contrast, Foxi2 is initially expressed broadly in cranial ectoderm with the striking exception of the otic placode, and ultimately becomes restricted to pharyngeal arch ectoderm. These expression patterns provide an insight into the roles of these transcriptional regulators during the development of the inner ear and pharyngeal arch derivatives.

Vertebrate cranial sensory organs and their ganglia originate from thickened ectoderm called cranial placodes. Despite the cellular and functional diversity of cranial sense organs, their precursors derive from the ectoderm adjacent to the anterior neural plate region called preplacodal region (PPR). The PPR is characterized by the expression of a unique set of transcription factors referred as PPR genes, which include Foxi, ERNI, Datch, GATA, Dlx, Six, and Eya. The expression analysis of these genes does not correlate precisely with phenotypes in the PPR. Knockouts of all PPR genes do not show complete loss of any cranial placodes. However, Foxi3 and Dlx5 genes are expressed early in the PPR in complementary fashion, with Dlx5 localized anteriorly and Foxi3 localized posteriorly. In addition, mutants of Dlx gene family members show defective anterior cranial members do not show defects in the induction of cranial placodes. All these genes are considered as PPR genes because of their expression in the PPR, but not all of them contribute to PPR induction. Placodes, and Foxi3 knockout mice show defects in posterior placodes. On the other hand, Six and Eya gene family members, mentioned as definitive PPR genes in previous studies, are expressed after Foxi3 and Dlx5. Moreover, mutants of Six and Eya gene family Vertebrate cranial sense organs largely arise from ectodermal thickening, the placodes. Albeit diverse in function, precursors of cranial sensory placodes are intermingled initially and derive from a common region called preplacodal region (