SYNOPSIS
U.S. and international auditing standard setters continue to raise questions about standard auditors' reports and are exploring alternatives to those reports. Government agencies and professional organizations are also raising questions about the auditor's report. These questions point to a continued existence of an “audit expectation gap.” To investigate perceptions and misperceptions regarding the auditor's report, we conducted focus groups with five different stakeholder groups—financial statement preparers (CFOs), users (bankers, analysts, and non-professional investors), and external auditors. This approach allows detailed comparisons between the perceptions of the different stakeholder groups affected by the auditor's report. Findings include that financial statement users value the audit, but do not read the entire auditor's report. It is not clear to users, preparers, and auditors what the auditor's report is intended to communicate or the level of assurance being provided by the report. Stakeholders offered numerous suggestions to improve the auditor's report, but they also recognize those suggestions could significantly change the auditor's risk profile and increase audit fees. We suggest future research to determine if potential changes to the auditor's report would change users' behavior and if any resulting benefits outweigh the additional risks and costs.
Electronic dissemination of financial reports on the World Wide Web is becoming ubiquitous for larger corporations in developed market economies. This form of reporting presents many challenges for the financial statement audit. It is critical that the audit profession proactively addresses those challenges or they will be certainly addressed by government regulatory bodies and the courts of law. Most large listed public companies in France, Germany and the UK provide electronic versions of their printed annual reports on the web. A survey was made of fortyfive large listed UK, French and German corporations. A total of thirty-six of these corporations published their annual financial statements in HTML or Adobe Corporation's Acrobat. Ten of the seventeen corporations reporting in HTML included the auditors' report on their website. None of these reports linked back to the auditors' own site. A number of issues arise when corporations provide their financial statement audits on the web. These issues include the ease with which the auditor's report can be changed without any indication that a change was made; the meaning of the look and feel of the auditor's report in a rapidly changing web environment; and the implications of hyperlinks to and from web-based auditors' reports as well as the location and placement of the auditors' reports.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.