Sequence-specific protein-DNA interactions are at the heart of the response of the tumor-suppressor p53 to numerous physiological and stress-related signals. Large variability has been previously reported in p53 binding to and transactivating from p53 response elements (REs) due, at least in part, to changes in direct (base) and indirect (shape) readouts of p53 REs. Here, we dissect p53 REs to decipher the mechanism by which p53 optimizes this highly regulated variable level of interaction with its DNA binding sites. We show that hemi-specific binding is more prevalent in p53 REs than previously envisioned. We reveal that sequences flanking the REs modulate p53 binding and activity and show that these effects extend to 4–5 bp from the REs. Moreover, we show here that the arrangement of p53 half-sites within its REs, relative to transcription direction, has been fine-tuned by selection pressure to optimize and regulate the response levels from p53 REs. This directionality in the REs arrangement is at least partly encoded in the structural properties of the REs. Furthermore, we show here that in the p21-5′ RE the orientation of the half-sites is such that the effect of the flanking sequences is minimized and we discuss its advantages.

The tumor suppressor protein p53 acts as a transcription factor, binding sequence-specifically to defined DNA sites, thereby activating the expression of genes leading to diverse cellular outcomes. Canonical p53 response elements (REs) are made of two decameric half-sites separated by a variable number of base pairs (spacers). Fifty percent of all validated p53 REs contain spacers between 1 and 18 bp; however, their functional significance is unclear at present. Here, we show that p53 forms two different tetrameric complexes with consensus or natural REs, both with long spacers: a fully specific complex where two p53 dimers bind to two specific half-sites, and a hemispecific complex where one dimer binds to a specific half-site and the second binds to an adjacent spacer sequence. The two types of complexes have comparable binding affinity and specificity, as judged from binding competition against bulk genomic DNA. Structural analysis of the p53 REs in solution shows that these sites are not bent in both their free and p53-bound states when the two half-sites are either abutting or separated by spacers. Cell-based assay supports the physiological relevance of our findings. We propose that p53 REs with long spacers comprise separate specific half-sites that can lead to several different tetrameric complexes. This finding expands the universe of p53 binding sites and demonstrates that even isolated p53 half-sites can form tetrameric complexes. Moreover, it explains the manner in which p53 binds to clusters of more than one canonical binding site, common in many natural REs.

EcoRII restriction endonuclease is specific for the 5′-CCWGG sequence (W stands for A or T); however, it shows no activity on a single recognition site. To activate cleavage it requires binding of an additional target site as an allosteric effector. EcoRII dimer consists of three structural units: a central catalytic core, made from two copies of the C-terminal domain (EcoRII-C), and two N-terminal effector DNA binding domains (EcoRII-N). Here, we report DNA-bound EcoRII-N and EcoRII-C structures, which show that EcoRII combines two radically different structural mechanisms to interact with the effector and substrate DNA. The catalytic EcoRII-C dimer flips out the central T:A base pair and makes symmetric interactions with the CC:GG half-sites. The EcoRII-N effector domain monomer binds to the target site asymmetrically in a single defined orientation which is determined by specific hydrogen bonding and van der Waals interactions with the central T:A pair in the major groove. The EcoRII-N mode of the target site recognition is shared by the large class of higher plant transcription factors of the B3 superfamily.

The tumor suppressor p53 acts as a transcription factor recognizing diverse DNA response elements (REs). Previous structural studies of p53-DNA complexes revealed non-canonical Hoogsteen geometry of A/T base pairs at conserved CATG motifs leading to changes in DNA shape and its interface with p53. To study the effects of DNA shape on binding characteristics, we designed REs with modified base pairs "locked" into either Hoogsteen or Watson-Crick form. Here we present crystal structures of these complexes and their thermodynamic and kinetic parameters, demonstrating that complexes with Hoogsteen base pairs are stabilized relative to those with all-Watson-Crick base pairs. CATG motifs are abundant in p53REs such as GADD45 and p53R2 related to cell-cycle arrest and DNA repair. The high-resolution structures of these complexes validate their propensity to adopt the unique Hoogsteen-induced structure, thus providing insights into the functional role of DNA shape and broadening the mechanisms that contribute to DNA recognition by proteins.

No abstract