Malic acid derived from fossil resources is currently applied in the food and beverage industries with a medium global production capacity. However, in the transition from a fossil-based to a bio-based economy, biotechnologically produced L-malic acid may become an important platform chemical with many new applications, especially in the field of biopolymers. In this review, currently used petrochemical production routes to DL-malic acid are outlined and insights into possible bio-based alternatives for microbial L-malic acid production are provided. Besides ecological reasons, the possibility to produce enantiopure L-malic acid by microbial fermentation is the biggest advantage over chemical synthesis. State-of-the-art and open challenges concerning production host engineering, substrate choice and downstream processing are addressed. With regard to production hosts, a literature overview is given covering the leading natural production strains of Aspergillus, Ustilago and Aureobasidium, as well as Escherichia coli as the most important engineered recombinant host. The utilization of renewable substrates as an alternative to glucose is emphasized in particular as a key aspect for a competitive bio-based production. Out of the alternative substrates discussed in this review, the industrial side-streams crude glycerol and molasses seem to be most promising for large-scale L-malic acid production.

Background Microbial malic acid production is currently not able to compete economically with well-established chemical processes using fossil resources. The utilization of inexpensive biomass-based substrates containing acetate could decrease production costs and promote the development of microbial processes. Acetate is a by-product in lignocellulosic hydrolysates and fast pyrolysis products or can be synthesized by acetogens during syngas fermentation. For the fermentation of these substrates, a robust microorganism with a high tolerance for biomass-derived inhibitors is required. Aspergillus oryzae is a suitable candidate due to its high tolerance and broad substrate spectrum. To pave the path towards microbial malic acid production, the potential of acetate as a carbon source for A. oryzae is evaluated in this study. Results A broad acetate concentration range was tested both for growth and malic acid production with A. oryzae. Dry biomass concentration was highest for acetic acid concentrations of 40–55 g/L reaching values of about 1.1 g/L within 48 h. Morphological changes were observed depending on the acetate concentration, yielding a pellet-like morphology with low and a filamentous structure with high substrate concentrations. For malic acid production, 45 g/L acetic acid was ideal, resulting in a product concentration of 8.44 ± 0.42 g/L after 192 h. The addition of 5–15 g/L glucose to acetate medium proved beneficial by lowering the time point of maximum productivity and increasing malic acid yield. The side product spectrum of cultures with acetate, glucose, and cultures containing both substrates was compared, showing differences especially in the amount of oxalic, succinic, and citric acid produced. Furthermore, the presence of CaCO3, a pH regulator used for malate production with glucose, was found to be crucial also for malic acid production with acetate. Conclusions This study evaluates relevant aspects of malic acid production with A. oryzae using acetate as carbon source and demonstrates that it is a suitable substrate for biomass formation and acid synthesis. The insights provided here will be useful to further microbial malic acid production using renewable substrates.

Whole-cell immobilization by entrapment in natural polymers can be a tool for morphological control and facilitate biomass retention. In this study, the possibility of immobilizing the filamentous fungus Aspergillus oryzae for l-malic acid production was evaluated with the two carbon sources acetate and glucose. A. oryzae conidia were entrapped in alginate, agar, and κ-carrageenan and production was monitored in batch processes in shake flasks and 2.5-L bioreactors. With glucose, the malic acid concentration after 144 h of cultivation using immobilized particles was mostly similar to the control with free biomass. In acetate medium, production with immobilized conidia of A. oryzae in shake flasks was delayed and titers were generally lower compared to cultures with free mycelium. While all immobilization matrices were stable in glucose medium, disintegration of bead material and biomass detachment in acetate medium was observed in later stages of the fermentation. Still, immobilization proved advantageous in bioreactor cultivations with acetate and resulted in increased malic acid titers. This study is the first to evaluate immobilization of A. oryzae for malic acid production and describes the potential but also challenges regarding the application of different matrices in glucose and acetate media.

Malic acid, mainly used as acidulant and taste enhancer in the food industry, is currently produced from fossil resources. In this study, microbial L-malate production with the filamentous fungus A. oryzae using the carbon source acetate was evaluated. Acetate is for example contained in biomass-derived substrates such as lignocellulosic hydrolysates and condensates of fast pyrolysis, thus avoiding competition with food production. Since research on malic acid synthesis from acetate is limited and reported productivities and yields are low, this work aimed to improve the process. First, different cultivation temperatures were tested. This parameter was found to affect the ratio between malic and succinic acid, which is the major by-product of organic acid production with A. oryzae. At 32°C, the malate share was highest (53.7 ± 1.6%), while it was lowest at 38°C (43.3 ± 1.1%) whereas succinate represented the main product (51.5 ± 1.0%). Besides the temperature, the type of nitrogen source was also found to affect malate synthesis as well as biomass production. In the pre-culture, the biomass concentration was increased by a factor of 3.4–3.9, and germination started earlier with the complex nitrogen sources yeast extract, casein hydrolysate and peptone compared to the defined nitrogen source (NH4)2SO4. Especially with yeast extract, malate synthesis in the main culture was accelerated and the titer obtained after 48 h was about 2.6 times higher than that quantified with (NH4)2SO4. To reduce substrate inhibition in acetate medium, fed-batch and repeated-batch processes were evaluated using (NH4)2SO4 or yeast extract as nitrogen source. In the fed-batch process, the period of malate production was extended, and the maximum product concentration was increased to 11.49 ± 1.84 g/L with (NH4)2SO4 and 12.08 ± 1.25 g/L with yeast extract. In the repeated-batch process, the total acid production was highest within the first 240 h of fermentation, but optimization is required to maintain high production rates in later cycles. The lessons learned in this study will help in the development of further process strategies to maximize malate production using acetate as alternative substrate to the commonly used glucose.

Background Malic acid, a dicarboxylic acid mainly used in the food industry, is currently produced from fossil resources. The utilization of low-cost substrates derived from biomass could render microbial processes economic. Such feedstocks, like lignocellulosic hydrolysates or condensates of fast pyrolysis, can contain high concentrations of acetic acid. Acetate is a suitable substrate for l-malic acid production with the filamentous fungus Aspergillus oryzae DSM 1863, but concentrations obtained so far are low. An advantage of this carbon source is that it can be used for pH control and simultaneous substrate supply in the form of acetic acid. In this study, we therefore aimed to enhance l-malate production from acetate with A. oryzae by applying a pH-coupled feeding strategy. Results In 2.5-L bioreactor fermentations, several feeding strategies were evaluated. Using a pH-coupled feed consisting of 10 M acetic acid, the malic acid concentration was increased about 5.3-fold compared to the batch process without pH control, resulting in a maximum titer of 29.53 ± 1.82 g/L after 264 h. However, it was not possible to keep both the pH and the substrate concentration constant during this fermentation. By using 10 M acetic acid set to a pH of 4.5, or with the repeated addition of NaOH, the substrate concentration could be maintained within a constant range, but these strategies did not prove beneficial as lower maximum titers and yields were obtained. Since cessation of malic acid production was observed in later fermentation stages despite carbon availability, a possible product inhibition was evaluated in shake flask cultivations. In these experiments, malate and succinate, which is a major by-product during malic acid production, were added at concentrations of up to 50 g/L, and it was found that A. oryzae is capable of organic acid production even at high product concentrations. Conclusions This study demonstrates that a suitable feeding strategy is necessary for efficient malic acid production from acetate. It illustrates the potential of acetate as carbon source for microbial production of the organic acid and provides useful insights which can serve as basis for further optimization.