a b s t r a c tArginine-rich cell-penetrating peptides are short cationic peptides capable of traversing the plasma membranes of eukaryotic cells. While successful intracellular delivery of many biologically active macromolecules has been accomplished using these peptides, their mechanisms of cell entry are still under investigation. Recent dialogue has centered on a debate over the roles that direct translocation and endocytotic pathways play in internalization of cell-penetrating peptides. In this paper, we review the evidence for the broad range of proposed mechanisms, and show that each distinct process requires negative Gaussian membrane curvature as a necessary condition. Generation of negative Gaussian curvature by cell-penetrating peptides is directly related to their arginine content. We illustrate these concepts using HIV TAT as an example.

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs), such as the HIV TAT peptide, are able to translocate across cellular membranes efficiently. A number of mechanisms, from direct entry to various endocytotic mechanisms (both receptor independent and receptor dependent), have been observed but how these specific amino acid sequences accomplish these effects is unknown. We show how CPP sequences can multiplex interactions with the membrane, the actin cytoskeleton, and cell-surface receptors to facilitate different translocation pathways under different conditions. Using "nunchuck" CPPs, we demonstrate that CPPs permeabilize membranes by generating topologically active saddle-splay ("negative Gaussian") membrane curvature through multidentate hydrogen bonding of lipid head groups. This requirement for negative Gaussian curvature constrains but underdetermines the amino acid content of CPPs. We observe that in most CPP sequences decreasing arginine content is offset by a simultaneous increase in lysine and hydrophobic content. Moreover, by densely organizing cationic residues while satisfying the above constraint, TAT peptide is able to combine cytoskeletal remodeling activity with membrane translocation activity. We show that the TAT peptide can induce structural changes reminiscent of macropinocytosis in actin-encapsulated giant vesicles without receptors.protein transduction domain | polyarginine | peptide-lipid interactions | pore-forming peptide | antimicrobial peptide C ell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are effective intracellular delivery systems (1-5). These peptides are usually short (<20 amino acids) and cationic. Examples include the TAT peptide from HIV, antennapedia (ANTP) from Drosophila, and even simple polyarginines. Although unique molecular architectures incorporating CPPs have been designed for drug delivery (3, 6-8), the molecular mechanisms of cellular entry, and the relations between them, are not well understood. Different uptake mechanisms have been proposed for CPPs (9). Cell-based assays have indicated that multiple endocytotic pathways are involved (10-15). In addition to these, CPPs are also capable of direct entry mechanisms* (17-20). In general, cell-penetrating activity of CPPs has proven to be difficult to eliminate completely using a specific set of conditions (3,12,21), suggesting the existence of multiple mechanisms. A unified understanding of CPPs, which is currently lacking, must engage why the same sequence can readily activate the qualitatively distinct outcomes.How do relatively simple molecules like HIV TAT peptide facilitate mechanisms as different as direct translocation, and multiple endocytotic processes? Rather than debate priority between mechanisms, we focus on the physical chemistry of what these different mechanisms and CPPs have in common. Here, we show how the TAT peptide can multiplex different interactions with the same sequence, thus interacting with the membrane, the actin cytoskeleton, and specific receptors to produce multiple pathways of translocation under different condition...

Defensins comprise a potent class of membrane disruptive antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) with well-characterized broad spectrum and selective microbicidal effects. By using high-resolution synchrotron small angle x-ray scattering to investigate interactions between heterogeneous membranes and members of the defensin subfamilies, α-defensins (Crp-4), β-defensins (HBD-2, HBD-3), and θ-defensins (RTD-1, BTD-7), we show how these peptides all permeabilize model bacterial membranes but not model eukaryotic membranes: defensins selectively generate saddle-splay (‘negative Gaussian’) membrane curvature in model membranes rich in negative curvature lipids such as those with phosphoethanolamine (PE) headgroups. These results are shown to be consistent with vesicle leakage assays. A mechanism of action based on saddle-splay membrane curvature generation is broadly enabling, since it is a necessary condition for processes such as pore formation, blebbing, budding, vesicularization, all of which destabilize the barrier function of cell membranes. Importantly, saddle-splay membrane curvature generation places constraints on the amino acid composition of membrane disruptive peptides. For example, we show that the requirement for generating saddle-splay curvature implies that a decrease in arginine content in an AMP can be offset by an increase in both lysine and hydrophobic content. This ‘design rule’ is consistent with the amino acid compositions of 1,080 known cationic AMPs.

The M2 protein is a multi-functional protein, which plays several roles in the replication cycle of the influenza A virus. Here we focus on its ability to promote budding of the mature virus from the cell surface. Using high resolution small angle X-ray scattering we show that M2 can restructure lipid membranes into bicontinuous cubic phases which are rich in negative Gaussian curvature (NGC). The active generation of negative Gaussian membrane curvature by M2 is essential to influenza virus budding. M2 has been observed to colocalize with the region of high NGC at the neck of a bud. The structural requirements for scission are even more stringent than those for budding, as the neck must be considerably smaller than the virus during ‘pinch off’. Consistent with this, the amount of NGC in the induced cubic phases suggests that M2 proteins can generate high curvatures comparable to those on a neck with size 10x smaller than a spherical influenza virus. Similar experiments on variant proteins containing different M2 domains show that the cytoplasmic amphipathic helix is necessary and sufficient for NGC generation. Mutations to the helix which reduce its amphiphilicity and are known to diminish budding attenuated NGC generation. An M2 construct comprising the membrane interactive domains, the transmembrane helix and the cytoplasmic helix, displayed enhanced ability to generate NGC, suggesting that other domains cooperatively promote membrane curvature. These studies establish the importance of M2-induced negative Gaussian curvature during budding and suggest that antagonizing this curvature is a viable anti-influenza strategy.